“The right way to wholeness is made up, unfortunately, of fateful detours and wrong turnings.” C.G. Jung Collected Works Vol. 12, paragraph 6.

Opening the Door to Wisdom

So many times, regret is the thing that brings people into the consulting room. Something has happened that has them question all that they are.

A woman I’ll call M came to me not long after leaving a marriage of nineteen years. She did not want to talk about the marriage. She wanted to talk about the year before she left it, a year she referred to only as “the mistake,” as though twelve months could be filed under a single containable word. There had been an affair. It ended the marriage, though not the way she expected, not with drama but with a slow unraveling that took another two years to finish. What she wanted in that first session was not understanding. She wanted removal. She wanted help extracting that year the way a surgeon removes something diseased, cleanly, so what remained could go back to being the person she thought herself to be.

This is a familiar conversation. Only the particulars change. The year becomes a business that failed, a friendship betrayed, a child left too often in the name of a career that has since stopped meaning anything. Underneath it all is an ego’s cry: take me back to who I was before I did this. Or, more precisely, tell me how to become the wiser version of myself as quickly as possible, so I never have to be the person who did this terrible thing.

Regret is a curious experience. It can lead to self-castigation or fodder for the inner critic, wreaking harshness on an already fragile ego.

There is a belief hiding underneath that want, common enough that we rarely stop to examine it.

Fallen Sophia

Gnostic texts of the first centuries describe the Goddess of Wisdom Sophia’s fall. She is a central feminine aeon (divine emanation) in Gnostic cosmology. This version of her story is told in the Apocryphon of John. 

The story goes like this. Sophia, the last and youngest of the aeons, acts alone and out of a passionate desire to understand or emulate the unknowable Father. Without her consort, and without permission from her counterparts in the divine realm,  she reaches for something beyond what she was given. She has the longing to know the origin, divinity, and ultimate reality. In reaching, she errs.

She reaches beyond the limits appropriate to her own nature, and she falls. Falls into darkness, and this produces a flawed world. A material, imperfect, and unfinished world of the human condition and matter.

Here is where the story could have gone the way M wanted her own story to go. Sophia could have been corrected. Drawn back into the fullness she fell from, her mistake undone, the flawed world quietly erased along with the wisdom that made it. That would have been the tidy version. The one where the fall is a detour and wisdom is the destination you reach once the detour is behind you.

That is not what happens. Sophia stays.

She does not get extracted from the world her error made. She remains inside it, entangled in the very matter her fall produced, and it is precisely her staying that allows that world to hold any meaning at all. Not despite the fall. Because of it. Her presence there, unresolved, unrescued, is what makes the material world capable of carrying the sacred rather than simply excluding it.

The question I could not answer for M in that first session was how quickly she could become the wiser version of herself. That question was built on a premise the oldest story about wisdom does not support.

Wisdom was never waiting on the other side of her mistake. It was not a country she would reach once the year she called “the mistake” was sufficiently atoned for and left behind.

Wisdom was already in the mistake. It was made of the same matter the mistake was made of. And the only way to reach it was to stay in it.

Individuation, Not Therapy

M came into session wanting to be healed of something, wanting to be healed from the mistake. This was the goal of coming to therapy:  her words, not mine.

Healing, in this sense, assumes an injury, like a cut or a broken bone that can be restored to a prior condition, uninjured, or at least functional again, restored to some baseline that existed before the wound. Healed, in this sense, means the thing that happened to you no longer determines who you are. You get your life back. You get yourself back.

Therapy, in its ordinary sense, has a destination. You arrive damaged; you leave functional. The fall is the problem. Resolution is the goal. Symptom reduction is how you know it worked.

Individuation has no such finish line. Jung was explicit that it isn’t ego-repair or a return to normal functioning. It is the lifelong process of becoming the specific person you already are, shadow included, and it doesn’t conclude when you feel better. Individuation doesn’t remove you from the world. It gathers the world into you.

That’s the same shape as what Sophia’s myth is doing. If wisdom were therapy, the goal would be to extract her from matter, undo the mistake, return her to the Pleroma intact. But that’s not how the myth resolves. She isn’t cured of her fall. She’s found within it, and her presence there is what makes the material world capable of holding meaning at all.

Have you found value here? Have you been inspired or moved?  Please consider sharing the post on your social media networks by using the buttons below.

I love to hear your comments and ideas. Use the comments below or send me an email.